Henri Bergson ( – ) introduced new life to French philosophy, examining the non-mathematical sciences from a philosophical stance. He introduced. Henri Bergson, Duration and Simultaneity: Bergson and the Einsteinian Universe Time, Duration and Freedom – Bergson’s Critical Move Against Kant. Duration and Simultaneity. Henri Bergson Henri Bergson in 20th Century Philosophy Concepts of Simultaneity: From Antiquity to Einstein and Beyond.

Author: Golrajas Dir
Country: Belize
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Relationship
Published (Last): 15 January 2011
Pages: 310
PDF File Size: 20.19 Mb
ePub File Size: 5.16 Mb
ISBN: 812-1-92893-213-3
Downloads: 18826
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Daill

He accepts this because it eimultaneity not happen. But, there is another kind of morality and religion, according to Bergson. We shall return to this problem of Bergson’s temporary disappearance from the philosophical scene.

This made me want to read Bergson and judge for myself, which Simultaheity duly did and soon saw how wrong Russell was. Yet these concepts put side-by-side can never adequately represent duration itself. More- over, if real duration becomes divisible, as we shall see, by means of the community that is established between it and the line symbolizing it, it consists in itself of an indivisible and total progress.

Simuotaneity, if each body, taken individually and arrested where our habits of perception bound it, is in great part a being of con- vention, why would this not be so for the motion considered to be affecting this body individually?

Duration and simultaneity – CERN Document Server

But, this hypothesis does not yet account for evolution in the diversity of its products, nor does it explain the principle of the wnd of life. Of these two acts, the first is the essential one in the measurement of time.

It is the “generalized” theory of relativity. There are experimental grounds for believing that he will at once observe a shift of the spectrum line the “Doppler ef- fect”.

We shall then say that we havemeasured the time of this unwinding and of the universal unwinding as well. Henri Bergson in 20th Century Philosophy. Bergson suggests that the traditional association between the model of space and time is incoherent. Let the “quietly seated” More decide to run in his turn, let him get up and run: In just the same way the thousands of successive positions of a runner are contracted into one sole symbolic attitude, which our eye perceives, which art reproduces, and which becomes for everyone the image of a man who runs Matter and Memorypp.

To claim that one can measure real duration by counting separate spatial constructs is an illusion: I have tried to direct attention to the danger inherent in this situation, but without success; my attempt to bring it to the attention of the potential victims has been refused publication by both the scientific and the nonscientific press-the latter understandably, since it must be almost impossible for the layman to believe that the scientist, whose reputation for absolute integrity has become proverbial, can really behave in such a way.


This is what y – v 2 we would see again, without directly considering the composi- tion of speeds in the following manner. Indeed, for Bergson and this is the center of his truly novel idea of memory, memory conserves the past and this conservation does not imply that one experiences the same re-cognitionbut difference. An Introduction to Henri BergsonIthaca: And thus, even though we cannot know all durations, every single one that comes into existence must be related, as a part, to the others.

Instead of fearing time and thinking of it as an endless space that has to be filled in, we would value it more and make sure we had time to express our own particular form of creativity, time to dream, time to do nothing in particular, to have a fallow period, time to sit silently, or walk mindfully.

As a result of this natural need, society inculcates habits of obedience in the individual. For us, it is the earth’s rotation that is the model motion tracing the path of time. But I pass through them, and what you perceive from your fixed observatory happens to appear quite differ- ently to me.

Instead, let us imagine an infinitely small piece of elastic, contracted, if that were possible, to a mathematical point. Indiana University Press, If Deleuze’s interpretation is correct, the confrontation that Duration and Simultaneity develops is not one between Bergson and Einstein but a confrontation between Bergson’s interpretation of multiplicities and Riemann’s interpretation of multiplicity, Riemann’s interpretation being, according to Deleuze, the basis of Einstein’s theory Deleuze,pp.

But the outstanding discrepancy was with Newton’s first law, or the principle of relativity, as it had come to be called. Yet it is manifestly so, as any- one who cares to read the literature can verify for himself. Third, one should make the effort to differentiate as with the color orange the extremes of this heterogeneity.

The danger, which I think he saw instinctively but was not able effectively to avert, was that of mistaking ideas for experiences, symbols for obser- vations. Bergson’s second book, Matter and Memoryappeared in This essentially pragmatic, hence analytic and quantitative orientation of intelligence precludes its immediate access to the essentially qualitative nature of life.

By a communication established between the two in- dividuals entrusted with the synchronizing. Let us fix our attention not on the line as line, but on the action which traces it. Bergson died on January 3, at the age of Bergson also calls the last characteristic of temporal progress mobility. Henri Bergson Free will Philosophy of time Concepts in metaphysics. In most cases, the assimilation of the system of reference to an aggregate system of this type offers no objec- tion.


But if, on the other hand, we subscribe to Ein- stein’s theory, the multiple times will remain; but there will never be more than a single real one among them, as we pro- pose to demonstrate; the others will be mathematical fictions.

The simlutaneity of this image is that it presents a continuity of experiences without juxtaposition. Hence, if the postulate of relativity is true, the clocks must be retarded equally or not at all: This paper of Einstein’s seems to be little known: If we make more of an effort, we sense that the darkest shade of orange is a different color, red, while the lightest is also a different color, yellow.

As Deleuze will show in his cinema books, dudation, Bergson does not recognize the novelty of this artform. Each of us is generally simultanelty with indefinitely en- larging, by a vague effort of imagination, his immediate physi- cal environment, which, being perceived by him, participates in the duration of his consciousness.

Duration and Simultaneity

Lorentz’ the- ory was what he called “half-relativity” or “unilateral rela- tivity”: The experiment is con- ducted without reference to a clock or to time, so the effect, if any, of motion on clocks cannot account for the observations.

So much, at least, for ponderable matter, for what I carry along with me in the motion of my system; drastic changes have occurred in the temporal and spatial relations of its parts, but I am not, nor need I be, aware of them.

The individual at O has dispatched to the one at A a beam of light intended to return to him immedi- ately. It is memory, but not personal memory, external to what it retains, distinct from a past whose simultaneiity it assures; it is a memory within change itself, a memory that prolongs the before into the after, keeping them from being mere snap- shots appearing and disappearing in a znd ceaselessly re- born.